Changes at Downing Street
A new occupant is expected to move into the Prime Minister’s office at 10 Downing Street in the near future. However, social media commentary suggests this may amount to little more than a change of nameplate rather than any meaningful shift in direction.Andy Burnham will soon be hated even more than Keir Starmer,’ ran the headline of a column by The Telegraph commentator Michael Deacon. He argues that one of the key issues is that the former Mayor of Greater Manchester would become the first Prime Minister in around 60 years not to have been elected via a general election, raising questions over his democratic legitimacy. As a result, the journalist suggests, voters are likely to view his initiatives with suspicion from the outset.
A wider debate has also erupted online over whether Burnham’s rise would actually change anything in practice. Many point out that the governing party would remain essentially the same, with Labour having announced no substantive policy reset.
Complaints Already Mounting
Criticism previously levelled at Burnham in the press and political commentary includes his frequent shifts in political position, calls for higher taxation and increased state intervention, and his failure to meet pledges to reduce homelessness in Greater Manchester. User Pete Sanford has also highlighted what he describes as a controversial £800 million arrangement with a Manchester property developer during Burnham’s time as chair of the city’s finance committee, as well as contracts awarded by Greater Manchester to a firm linked to the mayor’s wife.
The Migration Question
Another line of criticism concerns Burnham’s stance on immigration policy, with concerns that he would not support Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood’s efforts to tighten rules on migrants seeking permanent residency.
Against this backdrop, Labour has also been reminded of the grooming gangs scandal that shocked the country, involving organised groups of men, largely of Pakistani origin, who systematically targeted vulnerable teenage girls from disadvantaged backgrounds, children’s homes, and street settings, supplying them with alcohol and drugs before subjecting them to serious abuse. Official reports suggest thousands of cases nationwide.
When Burnham was Mayor of Greater Manchester, the local inquiry into the scandal effectively led nowhere. Meanwhile, Labour also blocked calls for a full national inquiry into grooming gangs. As a result, some believe the list of political and reputational challenges facing both the party and its prospective new leader is unlikely to stop growing.